Courage in Leadership: Mastering the Art of Upward Feedback

Unsplash @pttiedu

How One Leader Overcame His Fears to Address Crucial Issues

As leaders, we often find ourselves in situations where we need to provide feedback - not just to our direct reports but also to our superiors. This upward feedback can be particularly challenging, as it requires courage, tact, and a delicate balance of respect and honesty. Austin, a manufacturing plant manager at a large automotive plant, recently faced such a dilemma when he needed to address his boss's negative comments about hourly workers.

Austin's situation is not uncommon. Many leaders struggle with giving feedback to their superiors, fearing potential repercussions or damaging the relationship. However, these crucial conversations, when handled thoughtfully, can lead to positive outcomes, fostering team morale, productivity, and organizational culture.

So, how can leaders overcome their fears and effectively provide feedback to their bosses? Here are some key strategies:

1. Gain clarity: Before initiating the conversation, ensure you clearly understand the issue at hand. Austin reflected on specific instances where his boss's comments were problematic, allowing him to articulate the situation more effectively.

2. Use a structured approach: Employ a feedback model like SBI (Situation, Behavior, Impact) to frame your message. This helps keep the feedback objective and focused on specific behaviors rather than personal judgments.

3. Practice and prepare: Rehearse your feedback alone or with a trusted colleague or coach. This can help you refine your message and boost your confidence.

4. Choose the right time and place: Timing is crucial when delivering feedback. Find an appropriate moment when your boss will likely be receptive and not rushed or stressed.

5. Ask for permission: Start the conversation by asking if it's a good time to share observations or feedback. This shows respect and allows the recipient to be mentally prepared.

6. Focus on the impact: Clearly articulate how the behavior affects you, the team, and the organization. Austin realized that his boss's negative comments were demotivating other team members and potentially harming the company's culture change efforts.

7. Offer solutions: Come prepared with suggestions for improvement or alternative approaches. This demonstrates a constructive mindset and shows you're committed to finding solutions.

8. Be open to dialogue: Feedback is a two-way street. Be prepared to listen to your boss's perspective and engage in a meaningful conversation about the issue.

9. Follow up: Discuss progress and any changes observed after the initial conversation. This reinforces the importance of the feedback and shows your commitment to ongoing improvement.

While giving feedback to your boss can be daunting, it's an essential skill for effective leadership. By addressing issues head-on, you contribute to a more positive work environment and demonstrate your commitment to the organization's success.

Austin's journey reminds us that growth often lies outside our comfort zone. As he prepared to have this crucial conversation with his superior, he faced his fears and took a significant step in his leadership development. By modeling the behavior of giving constructive feedback, Austin set an example for his team and contributed to a culture of open communication.

Remember, providing upward feedback isn't about criticism; it's about you, as a leader, fostering a culture of continuous improvement and mutual respect. Your role in this can strengthen relationships, improve organizational effectiveness, and showcase your leadership capabilities when done thoughtfully and professionally.

So, the next time you find yourself hesitating to give feedback to your boss, remember Austin's experience. Take a deep breath, prepare thoroughly, and step forward with confidence. Your courage to have these difficult conversations may catalyze positive organizational change.

For more Insights articles on leadership, coaching, and mentoring, visit www.advance.net/insights. If you prefer Podcasts, listen to our latest episode of Mentor Leadership.

Enjoy your next feedback conversation!

The Silent Voice: When the Team Goes Quiet

@smartworkscoworking

Have you ever experienced the feeling of your voice being marginalized and your ideas and expertise being persistently overlooked?

In my recent work coaching, I've witnessed this painful dynamic firsthand as I observed an exceptional employee, whom we'll call Emily, a Communication Director, ironically given her role, losing her voice amidst the power dynamics of a team led by a newly hired executive, Sarah.

Despite Emily's competence and dedication, Sarah's unconscious need to assert her value in the executive role inadvertently overshadowed Emily's contributions. Sarah's approach unwittingly silenced the diverse perspectives and innovative thinking that Emily brought. Instead of having her expertise elevated and her insights heard, Emily was sidelined and marginalized.

Emily's silencing had a devastating impact on the rest of the team. Their synergy and productivity plummeted as crucial ideas went unheard. Morale dwindled as frustration and disillusionment set in. Worst of all, the once-vibrant Emily began to withdraw, her confidence eroded by the persistent disregard for her talents. The air went out of the room.

When conversation slows, so begins the erosion of trust.

Have you ever found yourself in a similar situation, feeling powerless to find your voice and make it heard? What steps did you take to advocate for yourself and reclaim your rightful place at the table? Perhaps a mentor or ally stepped in to champion your cause and amplify your perspective.

As a leader, have you ever caught yourself monopolizing discussions or promoting your agenda at the expense of your team's voices? It's a common pitfall driven by a genuine but misguided desire to prove one's worth. However, the cost of this behavior can be severe - lost innovation, decreased morale, and the alienation of top talent.

Who in your life and work seems to have lost their voice when you're in the room?

This scenario underscores the critical importance of effective leadership in fostering a culture of collaboration, respect, and recognition. Leaders must recognize each team member's value and actively cultivate an environment where diverse perspectives are welcomed and honored. Failure to do so stifles progress and risks eroding team cohesion and losing irreplaceable talent.

Through targeted coaching and courageous feedback from her direct reports, Sarah raised her self-awareness and started recognizing Emily's silent voice. By fostering empathy and understanding, Sarah began actively engaging Emily's expertise - catalyzing a revitalization of team dynamics and renewed productivity.

Sarah's experience strongly reminds us that authentic leadership does not involve dominating the spotlight but elevating the brilliance of those around you. A leader must create an environment where every voice is heard, respected, and empowered to contribute. This is the only way to ensure teams thrive and achieve extraordinary results.

Take a moment to look at your experiences. When have you ever felt marginalized? Who's the person or people who advocated for you? Understanding how they made a difference and learning from their actions is crucial.

As a leader, it's your responsibility to amplify the voices of everyone on your team. Each team member has a unique perspective that can contribute to the team's success. Therefore, you must provide a platform to harness the collective genius of all. By doing so, you can ensure that your team achieves its goals and exceeds expectations.